the best pro wrestling podcast episodes

Why this pick: Directly addresses the query by debating what will be the best match at WWE SNME and AEW Double or Nothing, alongside reviews of weekly shows from WWE and AEW. Cultaholic's Maffew, Ross, and Joel provide informed, discussion-heavy analysis on match quality, booking, and standout performances. This high-quality, recent episode is perfectly tailored for fans seeking expert opinions on pro wrestling's premier bouts and events.

Why this pick: This discussion-style episode directly tackles wrestling's biggest debates, including Bret Hart vs Shawn Michaels, the impact of major signings like the Outsiders to WCW versus Cody Rhodes and CM Punk to WWE, and the most influential weapons in wrestling history like tables, ladders, or chairs. It provides deep analysis on pro wrestling's pivotal moments and figures, making it highly relevant for fans seeking insightful 'best of' style content. The format encourages lively debate, aligning perfectly with the user's preference for discussion-oriented podcasts.

Why this pick: Sean Ross Sapp delivers a comprehensive review and highlights from AEW Double or Nothing 2026, questioning if it's the best PPV of the year with analysis of the World Title hair match, women's championship, and multiple tournament bouts. It includes expert insights on key matches like Okada vs Takeshita and Stadium Stampede. As a well-produced discussion with Fightful's top reporter, it provides high-value, timely evaluation of top-tier pro wrestling events.

Why this pick: This episode debates whether AEW Double or Nothing 2026 was the best PPV ever, analyzing elements like pacing, match order, and presentation that set it apart. It covers Mick Foley's AEW signing, FTR's future, and contrasts with WWE events like Saturday Night's Main Event, providing comparative perspectives on pro wrestling quality. The discussion style with hosts JDfromNY and others offers credible, in-depth takes on current industry highs and lows.

Why this pick: A thorough review of AEW's Double or Nothing PPV, evaluating if it's one of the best shows in company history with detailed breakdowns of standout matches like the 'I Quit' match, Takeshita vs Okada as potential Match of the Year, and the Darby vs MJF rematch. The hosts Trish and Sarah offer balanced opinions on key moments including Mick Foley's AEW debut and Kevin Knight's turn. This discussion-focused episode delivers practical insights into what makes a pro wrestling event exceptional.

Why this pick: This TNT episode compares WWE Clash in Italy to AAA's event led by Undertaker, debating if it upstaged Triple H and evaluating the best feud/match of the weekend with El Grande Americano. It covers tournament starts, roster news, and Bloodline storylines, questioning what defines top pro wrestling quality. The news and analysis format with JDfromNY and Solomonster provides diverse, high-energy discussion on current 'best' moments across promotions.

Why this pick: Focused on predictions for WrestleMania 42 Night 2, this discussion-style episode from Going In Raw analyzes potential outcomes and standout performances in one of WWE's biggest events. It offers fan perspectives on what could make matches memorable or historically significant. While more predictive than retrospective, it contributes to understanding 'best' elements in major pro wrestling PPVs through expert speculation and debate.

Why this pick: The Undertaker and Michelle McCool reflect on the best moments of 2025 in this reflective discussion, offering insider perspectives from one of wrestling's greatest. It covers top highlights from the year, providing unique value through a legend's viewpoint on what stands out in pro wrestling. Though slightly less recent, its focus on 'best of' curation and high-profile hosts makes it a strong, diverse addition to the list.