the best haunted podcast episodes
A hand-picked, playable selection of the best podcast episodes for this topic — each with the reason it earned its spot. Press play on any pick, or build your own playlist free.
Why these picks
8 episodes curated for "the best haunted podcast episodes"
The curated episodes
8 episodes — each chosen for a reason you can read below.
Why this pick: Listener Supported True Scary Stories Volume 15 is a perfect match as a 'best of' compilation of real haunted house encounters, creepy woods experiences, and unexplained visitors that listeners found unforgettable. It delivers pure storytelling of true horror in a chilling, immersive style ideal for the query. The extended 124-minute runtime allows deep dives into multiple high-impact tales, making it one of the highest quality and most directly relevant haunted episodes available.
Why this pick: This 50th episode Halloween Spooky Story Extravaganza features multiple guests sharing their creepiest real haunted tales designed to terrify listeners alone at night. As a special storytelling-focused episode from a long-running horror podcast, it excels in delivering diverse spooky narratives with strong production. Its festive Halloween theme and emphasis on stories that 'creep the hell outta ya' make it uniquely suited for fans seeking the best haunted podcast content.
Why this pick: Episode 52 celebrates the 'most haunted podcast in America' by investigating two legendary sites: the Congress Hotel and the Villisca Axe Murder House. It combines in-depth haunted location storytelling with historical murder lore in an engaging, well-edited format. This anniversary episode provides concrete haunted history and ghost stories, offering substantial value for listeners seeking authentic paranormal investigations.
Why this pick: You Invited Me presents multiple first-person haunted tales including a doppelganger Fetch from Irish folklore, a ghost mimicking a daughter in a new home, and a paranormal entity watching a newborn. The storytelling format mixes personal accounts with evidence like photos, creating immersive haunted experiences. As part of the acclaimed Scared to Death series, it delivers high-quality, detailed narratives perfect for the query's focus on the best haunted episodes.
Why this pick: Episode 10 – Halloween Horrors explores the history of Halloween while swapping classic campfire-style haunted tales and ghost stories. From the well-regarded Two Girls One Ghost podcast, it blends educational context with pure storytelling in a fun, accessible way. This seasonal episode stands out for connecting Halloween traditions directly to haunted narratives, providing both entertainment and background value.
Why this pick: S20 Ep56 compiles the best Ouija board stories from 13 seasons, focusing on terrifying real encounters with the dead through this infamous tool. The Monsters Among Us format presents firsthand witness accounts in a storytelling style, making it a strong haunted episode. It offers variety through multiple curated tales while addressing the debate between game and genuine paranormal device.
Why this pick: This 'Best of 2025' special selects the most terrifying spooky calls and paranormal stories from the year for Monsters Among Us. It functions as a haunted highlights reel with diverse ghost, cryptid, and unexplained encounters told directly by witnesses. The curation approach ensures only the strongest haunted narratives are included, providing an efficient way to experience top-tier storytelling from a popular series.
Why this pick: Best Selling Author Steven LaChance discusses his real-life experiences in a pure evil haunted rental home in Missouri, detailed in his book The Uninvited. The interview-style storytelling reveals lingering effects of the haunting and his broader paranormal insights. This high-credibility episode from a renowned author offers deep, personal haunted house narrative with literary context, rounding out the selection with expert perspective.